Dungeon Crawler Carl: The Graphic Novel, Vol. 2
by Matt Dinniman, Tevagah, Kuzomari, et al
Recommended Ages: 15+
This graphic novel, based on Dinniman's Dungeon Crawler Carl, is based on chaptes 14-30 of the webtoon series, following Vol. 1 (reviewed here). So, of course, I snagged a copy of it as soon as it materialized at the place where I'm always looking out for the latest paperbacks – Walmart. Again, there is a whole string of author-type credits on the cover, but I take Laurel Pursuit and Aethon to be a publisher and a webtoon studio. Dinniman created the source material; Tevagah and Kuzomari (a.k.a. Chistopher Krady) seem to be the actual, human manga artists. Correct me if I'm wrong.
If you've read the original novel, you hardly need another synopsis at this point, other than that this installment picks up just as Carl and Princess Donut blow up the goblin borough boss on Level 1 of the world dungeon. If you're joining late, he's a tragically shoeless and pantsless man and she's his ex-girlfriend's prize-winning cat. They recently survived the arrival of the aliens to destroy earth, only to become live combatants in an intergalactic game show where the survival is a cutthroat business tied, in part, to your popularity on social media. And now they start to meet other survivors, including a pair of "naughty" crawlers who have killed other people (not counting the "mobs," with whom it's strictly kill or be killed). Later, they join forces with a party of nursing home residents and staff who somehow survived the collapse, and are just hanging on. But to get to Level 2 before the whole floor pancakes down on top of them, they have to get past a floor boss that has already killed a bunch of people. So, I guess this is about the middle third of the original novel, culminating as our heroes are about to enter Floor 2 and get yanked out of the dungeon for a quick interview on a highly rated talk show.
The graphic novel translates the gripping middle part of the original book into vivid imagery, dramatizing the characters and laying some stress on the theme of Carl's resolve not to let the game break him. It's nice to see more human characters enter the frame. And I appreciate the fact that, compared to the first volume, I didn't have to strain my eyes as much to read the in-game notifications that present themselves to Carl and Donut. I do, however, have a new bone to pick with this adaptation – I was sometimes confused about the sequence of events. Callbacks to previous scenes, and visualizations of future and hypothetical events as well as scenes happening elsewhere, get mixed together in a way that more than once left me scratching my head and going back a page or so, to straighten it all out in my mind. Maybe it's me. Maybe I just haven't spent enough time with my nose in a graphic novel, conditioning myself to read them effectively. But while I like Carl and Co. as depicted by these manga artists, I think the vanilla novel just worked for me.
At any rate, it's a fast-paced read. Maybe to a fault. You get through what's left of Floor 1 in no time and sigh, wondering how long it'll be until Vol. 3 appears on the discount bookshelf. Meanwhile, there are a bunch more installments in Dinniman's series that have yet to fall into my lap. I've only personally seen a hardcover of the third book, The Dungeon Anarchist's Cookbook, and it's been a while since I've seen that in stock. So, maybe a paperback issue will be landing soon. I'm currently seeing hints that at least 10 books may be in store for fans of this series, with the eighth just released this year. If the paperbacks don't hurry up, I'm going to have to look for them in the library. I won't let them break me!
Saturday, October 31, 2026
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


No comments:
Post a Comment