Saturday, November 21, 2026

I Play Rocky

When I got home last night from my round trip to Detroit Lakes to see I Play Rocky, I knew just who I had to call: a friend from college with whom I had watched many a movie back in the day. I guess we didn't see Rocky together, as he pointed out. But we had a good time catching up and, of course, my description of this movie made his mouth water. It's an account of how a struggling actor calling himself Mike Stallone (until his girlfriend found out that his real given name was Sylvester, and said she liked it) went from sleeping on a stoop in New York City because he couldn't afford $7.50 a night to rent a room in a rathole hotel to writing and starring in the film that won Best Picture at the Academy Awards for 1976.

All it took was a girlfriend (later wife) who encouraged him to write a part for himself, since he wasn't getting parts anyone else was offering. He's like, "Who do you think I am, Orson Welles?" That, and inspiration striking in the form of a televised boxing match between Mohammed Ali and a hopeless challenger who refused to lie down and stay down, a couple of producers (Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff) who saw the potential in the script he had written, and his own dogged willingness to pass up a huge bonus for penning the script in order to play the role he had written for himself. And then he just had to survive a brutal shooting schedule that United Artists had designed to screw him over, hoping to trigger a clause where they could fire him if the shoot fell even one day behind, and replace him with (just imagine) Ryan O'Neal. In many ways, Stallone's actual character paralleled the one he wrote, refusing to give up on a dream even when everyone else told him it was crazy.

Playing young Sly is Anthony Ippolito, also known for playing Al Pacino in a miniseries about the making of The Godfather. Ippoloito delivers what is not only a spookily accurate impersonation of Stallone, from voice to physique to swagger, but also a sensitive and emotionally powerful performance as a guy who was (and I suppose, is) capable of writing intelligently, despite his dumb palooka image, but totally committed to his dream of being an actor. My only complaint about the casting is how unintentionally funny it is when Ippolito, who is actually indecently good-looking, makes references to his unfortunate lack of good looks, which has been holding him back.

Joining him in the cast are sometime child actor AnnaSophia Robb (Because of Winn-Dixie, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Bridge to Terabithia, Race to Witch Mountain) as Sly's wife, Sasha, who only clashes with her husband when he tries to hide the fact that he's being offered mountains of cash for his script and keeps saying no; Matt Dillon as his father, Frank, who tells him point blank to take the offer; P.J. Byrne (The Wolf of Wall Street) as Winkler; Toby Kebbell (RocknRolla and, unfortunely, 2015's Fantastic Four) as Chartoff; Stephan James (If Beale Street Could Talk) as Carl Weathers; and playwright Tracy Letts (August: Osage County) as a fictional studio executive in a show-stealing, satirical turn.

I'm going to go straight to the Three Scenes That Made It For Me before I think up five or six. (1) Winkler goes spare, watching his actors, who have never boxed before – Weathers actually lied at his audition and said he had, but that's what actors do – goading a boxing choreographer into quitting the picture. Later, Talia Shire admits on the day they're going to shoot the skating rink scene that she doesn't know how to skate (you know how actors lie), and Sly admits he doesn't skate either. Winkler: "Next time we make a movie, I'm going to make the actors take a polygraph!" (2) The film's entire cast and crew hides in a meat freezer while the New York Teamsters boss investigates rumors that Winkler and Chartoff are shooting a picture without his union. The con they put on him is perfection. (3) Rocky director John Avildsen explains to Stallone why he is set on shooting everything in one take. For Avildsen, it's about making the schedule – and he was hired, after all, because he knows how to make a picture fast and cheap. But then he adds that there will come a day when he makes Sly do a scene over and over until he gets it right, because unless he nails it, it won't be a great movie. Fans of Rocky, can you guess which scene it is when Avildsen's prediction pays off later? The scene they're shooting when Avildsen says, "I'm not buying it. I can't tell you what to do, only that you need to do something," and after coming back from a short break to think about it, Stallone nails it? Think about that, then check out the movie and see if you're right.

It's a fun movie. It has some good comic beats. It packs an emotional punch, no pun intended. There's an inspirational message at the bottom, about not giving up on your dreams, taking all kinds of hits and still getting up to fight on. I'm talking about this movie and the movie=within-a-movie, and the whole emotional arc of Stallone's creative process, all the way to his moment of panic at the premiere. And then Rocky gets to the top of the steps at the Philadelphia Musuem of Art and jumps in victory, and the audience at the premiere jumps up and cheers as well. Nice build-up, nice payoff. The other big payoff come in a title following a clip from Stallone's acceptance speech at the Oscars, which notes that he was only the second person to be nominated as best screenwriter and best actor for the same movie – after Orson Welles.

No comments: