Friday, April 6, 2012

On Bach's Passions

Of the Passion settings by J. S. Bach, the Matthew & John Passions are magnificent. What particularly moves me in them is the opening & closing choruses, the recitatives, and the "turbae" (numbers in which the chorus sings dialog from the passion text). The chorales & arias are lovely decorations, but if you take away Bach's dramatization of the Gospel text, all the life goes out of the work as a whole & it becomes nothing but so many pretty songs. The "passion" is gone. This is evident when you listen to the St Mark & St Luke passions of Bach, reconstructed (the same way Bach originally constructed them) from arias & chorales in his earlier cantatas. The words fit the music & all that, but the libretti (which survive although Bach's scores do not) are only the commentary; the thing itself is the passion text from the Gospels, and no one can reconstruct what Bach did with those texts in his recitatives & turbae. I have heard attempts to replace them with equivalent settings by other composers, but the results are uniformly boring. The loss of Bach's narrative music for the Mark & Luke passions is a tragedy over which I sincerely and deeply grieve.


ranjan said...

A very well-written post. I read and liked the post and have also bookmarked you. All the best for future endeavors.
IT Company India

ellieshilton said...

I’m seriously happy to discover this great site the future of this blog is getting good and more useful for me thanks and god bless you.
IT Learning